John C. Goodman makes my case about Republicans and conservatives not understanding how to fight the information war in this article about which of these two policies is more popular:
The simple answer is: Republicans don’t know how to govern. They certainly don’t know anything about the politics of reform.
This is understandable. For most of the 20th century, Democrats were on offense. Republicans were on defense. The job for the Democrats was to pass legislation. The task for Republicans was to stop them. Both parties got very good at their respective roles.
But when we got to the end of the 20th century – in this country and all over the world — the need was to dismantle the failing institutions the left had created. That meant privatization, deregulation and replacing command and control policies with individual choice and free markets.
Republicans had no experience doing this.
All the successful conservative reforms of the modern era have involved Democrats. Jimmy Carter championed deregulation – the airlines, transportation, communication, etc.— and brags about it to this day. Bill Clinton championed welfare reform and it’s been highly successful. Ronald Reagan’s tax reform was embodied in the Kemp/Roth bill. The Democrat’s Bradley/Gephardt bill was virtually the same and tax reform in 1986 was a bipartisan effort.
But when Republicans try to enact reforms on their own – without any Democratic help – they are not very good at it. In fact neither party has been very good at switching roles.
Based on the facts, Obamacare should be a disaster for Democrats this fall. As Bill Clinton observed, people are paying twice as much for half the coverage. Among those who don’t get any federal subsidy (everyone making more than, say, $50,000), premiums have doubled and tripled and there has been a 29% drop off – even though they face a fine for being uninsured next April 15th.
Read more: Forbes